What Is Not Here: Gaps, Dead Ends and a Warning About Ìjímèrè · Ìpilẹ̀ṣẹ̀
What Is Not Here: Gaps, Dead Ends and a Warning About Ìjímèrè
The tale types this section searched for and could not source, the collections it could not obtain, and why there is no monkey-trickster cycle and no Yorùbá origin-of-death tale in this corpus.
advancedhighìṣẹ́jú 11 kíkà·orísun 4
Decorative pattern for What Is Not Here: Gaps, Dead Ends and a Warning About Ìjímèrè
A corpus that only records what it found misrepresents the search. This file records what this section looked for and did not find, which collections were identified but could not be obtained, and two specific cases where the material that circulates online would have led straight into an error.
The zero-fabrication rule that governs this corpus means that a category can be requested, searched for thoroughly, and end with nothing written. That happened several times here, and the empty results are themselves findings.
Ìjímèrè the monkey: no trickster cycle could be sourced
This is the most important negative finding in the section, and it comes with a trap attached.
What could not be found. No sourced Yorùbá tale with Ìjímèrè as a trickster protagonist, and no monkey cycle comparable to the Ìjàpá cycle. Extensive searching produced nothing this compiler could cite.
What Ìjímèrè actually is. The Yorùbá name for the patas monkey, Erythrocebus patas. Its principal presence in the verbal-art record located here is a proverb rather than a tale: Ìjímèrè ṣọ́gigùn, kóo má baà gungi aládi, patas monkey, mind the trees you climb, lest you climb an aládi-infested tree, said of someone who acts without discretion, aládi being a small black ant that nests on tree stems. The corpus records this at second hand from the research consulted and has not verified it against a named proverb collection, so it is marked medium confidence and is not given a three-layer treatment here.
The trap. Searching "Ijimere Yoruba" leads quickly to Obotunde Ijimere, credited author of The Imprisonment of Obatala and other plays in the Heinemann African Writers Series. Obotunde Ijimere was a pen name invented by Ulli Beier, a German editor and scholar long resident in Nigeria. The name means roughly "Monkey has come back." It is a literary pseudonym, not a folk figure, and a researcher who meets it without knowing that will conclude there is an Ìjímèrè tradition where there is none.
The corpus flags this explicitly because the error is easy, the name is prominent in library catalogues, and nothing on the face of those catalogue entries reveals it.
What monkeys actually do in the sourced record. Where monkeys appear in material this section could source, they are never tricksters:
Wise counsellors. In Frobenius's account of how Ifá came to men, Èṣù (Frobenius's "Edju") goes to the palm trees and the monkeys give him sixteen nuts, and then instruct him: "Edju, do you not know what to do with the nuts? We will counsel you. You got the sixteen nuts by guile. Now go round the world and ask for their meaning everywhere. You will hear sixteen sayings in each of the sixteen places" . The monkeys see through him and tell him what to do.
Transformed children. Frobenius records an aetiology in which Ọbàtálá (his "Oshalla") transforms the children of Olókun into monkeys for going round his dwelling, closing: "Since that time Olokun's children gambol about like apes" .
A community with a chief. In Parkinson's hunter tale, alo-the-hunter-and-the-ape-with-sixteen-tails, the apes are a society with a leader, scouts and a deliberative process, and they are the victims.
That is the whole of it. The corpus states plainly that it did not find a monkey trickster, and does not assert that none exists in the Yorùbá-language collections it could not obtain.
The origin of death: not written, on purpose
A Yorùbá origin-of-death narrative circulates widely: Olódùmarè sends a message of eternal life by a goat, the goat lingers to eat, a sheep is sent instead and garbles the message so that men shall die, and the true message arrives too late to be believed .
This section does not carry that tale, and the reason is that every trail the research followed led to secondary or tertiary retellings rather than to a Yorùbá primary source or a named collector. It is not in Ellis's folklore chapter or his index. It is not in Frobenius volume one. The standard comparative monograph on the type across Africa is Hans Abrahamsson, The Origin of Death: Studies in African Mythology (Uppsala: Almqvist and Wiksell, 1951), which this compiler has not obtained.
The specific risk is that the messenger-of-death type is very widely distributed in West Africa, and the version in circulation may be Ashanti or Krachi material that has drifted onto a Yorùbá label . Writing it up on the strength of unsourced online retellings would be exactly the failure this corpus exists to avoid. The honest position is that the tale may well be Yorùbá and this section could not establish it.
Anyone extending this section should check Abrahamsson 1951 and Bolaji Idowu, Olódùmarè: God in Yoruba Belief (Longmans, 1962) directly before adding it.
Aetiologies searched for and not found
Why the hare has a short tail. Nothing Yorùbá-specific and sourced.
Why dogs and cats fight. Nothing Yorùbá-sourced. Note that this section does carry two dog aetiologies from Parkinson, alo-the-dog-and-the-tortoise and alo-the-pig-and-the-tortoise, but both explain the dog's relationship to the tortoise, not to cats.
Why the sun and moon are in the sky. Ellis carries related cosmological material in his chapter on minor gods, including an account of the stars as the moon's daughters and the sun's sons driven from the sky, but it is presented as belief rather than as an àlọ́ with a narrative frame, and it belongs to the cosmology section of this corpus rather than to a folktale section.
A misattribution worth flagging
Several search routes return "The Story of the Leopard, the Tortoise and the Bush Rat" as though it were Yorùbá . It is not. It comes from Elphinstone Dayrell, Folk Stories from Southern Nigeria, and is Efik or Ibibio material . Nigeria is not one tradition, and a tale collected in Calabar is not a Yorùbá àlọ́. The corpus records this because the misattribution is common and the tale is frequently reproduced without provenance.
Collections identified but not obtained
These exist, are relevant, and could not be read by this compiler. They are named so that anyone extending this section knows where to go, and so that nothing here is mistaken for a complete survey.
Yorùbá-language collections. These are the principal gap, and no amount of English-language searching substitutes for them.
Adeboye Babalọlá, Àkójọpọ̀ Àlọ́ Ìjàpá, Apá Kìíní and Apá Kejì (Ibadan: Oxford University Press, 1973; Part 2 dated 1979 in one source and 1973 in another, a discrepancy this compiler could not resolve). The major Yorùbá-language Ìjàpá collection. Only its opening formula reaches this section, at second hand through Kambon, in alo-the-opening-formula-and-the-teller.
Adun Amoo, Àkójọpọ̀ Àlọ́ Àpagbè (2010), named in yoruba-alo. No excerpts, reviews or contents listings could be found. A closely related Adebisi Amoo, Àlọ́ Àpagbè (Ibadan: Evans Brothers Nigeria, 1987) appears in a published bibliography; whether they are the same work could not be established.
Oyekan Owomoyela, Yoruba Trickster Tales (Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 1997). The standard scholarly collection of the Ìjàpá cycle, containing 23 tales. Not a single tale title or line of text from it reaches this section. Every access route was closed: archive.org lending restriction, search-inside unavailable, no publisher preview. This is the largest single gap in the section, and it is the more frustrating because Owomoyela's proverb collection is the backbone of owe-tortoise-ijapa-trickster.
Harold Courlander and Ezekiel A. Eshugbayi, Olode the Hunter, and Other Tales from Nigeria (New York: Harcourt, Brace and World, 1968), published in the United Kingdom as Ijapa the Tortoise, and Other Nigerian Tales (London: Bodley Head, 1969). 29 stories, mostly Yorùbá, with per-story notes and a dedicated essay on Ìjàpá. Eshugbayi was from Ilesha. Lending-restricted; the Ìjàpá essay in particular would be worth having.
Barbara K. Walker and Warren S. Walker, eds., Nigerian Folk Tales, as told by Olawale Idewu and Omotayo Adu (New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press, 1961). The best attribution quality identified anywhere in this research, since the narrators are named on the title page. Lending-restricted.
Ropo Sekoni, Folk Poetics: A Sociosemiotic Study of Yoruba Trickster Tales (Westport: Greenwood Press, 1994). The standing monograph on the narrative poetics of the cycle.
Abayomi Fuja, Fourteen Hundred Cowries: Traditional Stories of the Yoruba (Oxford University Press). Contains a leopard tale, "Concerning the Leopard and the Hedgehog," whose title only could be confirmed.
Bakare Gbadamosi and Ulli Beier, Not Even God Is Ripe Enough: Yoruba Stories (London: Heinemann Educational, African Writers Series 48, 1968). Its story titles are themselves proverbs, which places it squarely in the wisdom-and-folly register this section is thin on. Contents not obtainable.
Harold Courlander, Tales of Yoruba Gods and Heroes (New York: Crown, 1973). Orisha and heroic material rather than àlọ́.
Melville J. and Frances S. Herskovits, Dahomean Narrative: A Cross-Cultural Analysis (Evanston: Northwestern University Press, 1958).
One article. Olumide Olugbemi-Gabriel, "African Folktales and Social Order: A Study of Selected Yoruba Folktales," in Ademowo and Oladipo, eds., Engaging the Future in the Present: Issues in Culture and Philosophy (Ibadan: Hope Publications, 2015), pp. 46-55. Directly on topic; access blocked.
Leads that were checked and found empty
Recorded so that nobody repeats the work.
Frobenius, The Voice of Africa (1913). Both volumes searched in full. No Ìjàpá tales. Volume one has two non-narrative tortoise mentions, a carved tortoise on divination caskets and tortoises offered at a festival; volume two has none . The two monkey passages noted above are the only usable material .
William Bascom on Yorùbá tortoise tales. His well-cited Yorùbá articles concern divination, not tortoise tale texts. "The Relationship of Yoruba Folklore to Divining," Journal of American Folklore 56, no. 220 (1943), pp. 127-131, is a methodology piece. No Bascom-collected Ìjàpá tale text was located, and he should not be cited for one.
Lomax, "Stories of an African Prince: Yoruba Tales," Journal of American Folklore 26, no. 99 (1913). Genuinely Yorùbá, fully open access, narrated by Lattevi Ajaji. Downloaded and searched: zero tortoise tales among its fifteen.
Hambly, Talking Animals (1949). Many tortoise references, none Yorùbá; the material is Ovimbundu, from Angola.
Bọlanle Awe. Her published work is history, notably on Yorùbá women, not folktale collection.
Adeboye Babalọlá beyond the Ìjàpá collection. His other major work is on ìjálá, the hunters' chant, a separate genre treated in yoruba-ijala.
What this means for the section
Three consequences follow, and they should be read alongside every file here.
The section is built on what is open. Ellis 1894, Parkinson 1909, Ogumefu 1929, Frobenius 1913, one 2023 peer-reviewed article and one 2025 archive transcript. That is a sample shaped by copyright expiry and open-access policy, not by the tradition's own proportions. Three of the six are colonial-period British publications.
The Yorùbá-language record is almost entirely absent. Of the tales in this section, the songs surviving in Yorùbá come from one modern article and two nineteenth-century refrain words. The Yorùbá-language collections that would change this are listed above and none was obtainable.
The Ìjàpá cycle is over-represented here relative to what a full survey would show. Fifteen of this section's tale files are tortoise tales, not because the tradition is fifteen-sixteenths tortoise but because the tortoise material is what the open sources preserved at narrative length. Ellis prints four non-tortoise tales and six tortoise tales; Ogumefu prints thirty-one non-tortoise tales before her tortoise section begins, and this compiler could treat only six of them.
Àwọn orísun
[1]Frobenius, Leo, The Voice of Africa: Being an Account of the Travels of the German Inner African Exploration Expedition in the Years 1910-1912, Vol. I, trans. Rudolf Blind (London: Hutchinson and Co., 1913); the Ifá legend with the monkeys' counsel at pp. 229-232, introduced by Frobenius as "the legend as given to me by a dweller on the border of Kukurukuland"; the transformation of Olókun's children into monkeys at pp. 236-240. Public domain, https://archive.org/details/voiceofafricabei01frob. Colonial-era source, labelled as such; Frobenius's orthography is idiosyncratic (Edju for Èṣù, Oshalla for Ọbàtálá, Shankpanna for Ṣọ̀npọ̀nnọ́, Yemaya for Yemọja) and his framing belongs to early twentieth-century German ethnology. The volume is ethnography and archaeology rather than a folktale collection, and contains no Ìjàpá tales.
A note on this file's own sourcing. The negative findings above are reports of searches conducted for this section. Where a collection is named as unobtainable, the bibliographic details are as recorded in library catalogues and in the bibliography published at https://yorubatales.com/bibliography/; none of those works has been read by this compiler, and none is cited anywhere in this section as a source for any tale.